Everybody writes … but should they?

August 13th, 2014 by Bob Bly

My colleague Michael Stelzner recently did a podcast with a woman, AH, who wrote a forthcoming book called “Everyone Writes.”

AH is right: everyone writes. But I have always wondered whether everyone should write. And I have come to believe that they should not.

Reason: In the good old days, just because you wrote something didn’t mean it would be published. In fact, likely, it would not.

To get published, you had to convince a publishing house to buy your book – or a newspaper or magazine editor to print your article or your letter-to-the-editor … and most people were not able to do this easily. So what got published was vetted by professionals – and the quality reflected that editorial guidance.

But today, in the digital era, anything that anyone writes can be and often is instantly published to the Internet where theoretically millions of people can read it – and at least a few people, if only just your Facebook friends, almost certainly will.

Some people see this “everyone writes (and publishes)” phenomenon as a wonderfully liberating new age in human communication.

To me, it is the end of western civilization as we know it – and the death of literacy – and the heralding of an unceasing age of what I call endless “content pollution.”

Content pollution is everyone publishing every thought they have, and almost everything that happens to them, without the benefit of an editor or publisher to filter what goes out into the ether.

The job of the editor is quality control for written communication. Without editors, which the Internet has largely removed from the equation, the quality of published writing has fallen to a new low – not an easy accomplishment.

Example: Facebook posts featuring a picture of what the person has just eaten for breakfast. The amazing thing is that some readers actually seem interested!

The ease of publishing blogs, online newsletters, online articles, posts, and the like has caused amateur writing to flourish. And that’s bad news for professionals: it’s difficult to command a living wage for something thousands or even millions of people are happy to do for free, even if you are ostensibly better at it.

People ask me why I take the old-school stance of preferring traditional book publishing with NYC publishers to self-publishing on Amazon with Kindle.

The main reason is this: with traditional book publishing, you know that at least one person – the editor at the publishing house – thought highly enough of the work to pay for it. That’s a quality control self-publishing is sadly lacking.

Normally at this point in my essay I suggest solutions or give tips for profiting from the situation.

But I don’t really have a solution to content pollution. People feel compelled to express their thoughts, and thanks to the Internet, can do so at any time and are assured of at least some readers taking note.

There is nothing I can do to change the human compulsion to write and publish. I just wish more people who feel this compulsion would produce content at a higher level – that is, writing actually worth reading — and filter what they put on the web.


This entry was posted on Wednesday, August 13th, 2014 at 10:33 am and is filed under General. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

22 responses about “Everybody writes … but should they?”

  1. ALAT SEX said:


  2. ujan ca said:

    High quality back link get free in link submit

  3. Website said:

    great post keep it up

  4. Amit said:


    A format is a shape, form, or example utilized as a manual for making something. Here are a few cases:

  5. Amit said:

    Link successions in readiness for composing the code.

  6. Amit said:

    Flowcharting layouts (not utilized much now) enable how to fill out a fax cover sheet developers to draw flowcharts

  7. Amit said:

    BMI Chart Templates

  8. Ankur Pathania said:

    best invoice template

  9. Amit said:


  10. Amit said:


  11. Amit said:

    Click here

  12. Ankur Pathania said:

    formal resignation letter template

  13. Ankur Pathania said:


  14. titan gel said:

    nice for sharing

  15. komal kheni said:

    free gift card generator successions in readiness for composing the code.

  16. slope said:

    Very helpful advice in this particular post! It’s the little changes that make the largest changes. Thanks for sharing!

  17. vanita said:

    I’ll be sure to bookmark it and come back to read more of your useful info. Thanks for the post. I’ll definitely return. free gift card generator

  18. Kathy T. Hanks said:

    ban xoc dia bip
    camera nguy trang usb
    gia camera sieu nho khong day

  19. Anna Shetty said:

    we found that the pictures taken with front camera were really higher quality than anticipated good details, vivid shading and minimal noise.
    photoshop online, cool math games run 3

  20. gapps apk said:

    I found your post so interesting.
    gapps apk free download/b>

  21. al3abtabkh1 said:

    Thank you your subject is perfect and good, good luck brother for the next.

  22. congnghe9x said:

    camera sieu nho quay demcamera nguy trang wificác thiet b? nghe lén camera quay lén ket noi ?ien tho?i

Leave a Reply