Fruit by Mail: Why?
October 2nd, 2008 by Bob Bly
When I took his direct marketing course at NYU back in the early 1980s, Milt Piece taught us that “the ideal mail order product is one that is not available in stores.”
But the catalog company Harry & David sells mainly fruit (also chocolates and cakes) through mail order … all of which are also available in stores.
An article in the October issue of Catalog Success notes that Harry & David has annual sales well over half a billion dollars a year.
Why do you think they are able to generate these huge revenues selling mostly pears, apples, grapes, and other produce you can get at your local supermarket?
What’s the secret of Harry & David’s success?
Anyone?
This entry was posted on Thursday, October 2nd, 2008 at 3:17 pm and is filed under General. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.
October 2nd, 2008 at 3:32 pm
Laziness? More convenient to send gifts to people by ordering through those companies. Also, for those who the sender has no clue as to what they want or what they already has, and figures everyone eats.
Vanity (Exclusivity) for oneself in some circles. Maybe they feel if they say they get their fruit and candy from this company it’s like gourmet. (I’ve seen people do this.)
Pride at sending someone something “special” or “unique” because it came from that supplier.
Curiosity – if enough people have to order, just to see what’s so special about these products. (Better taste good for back up sales!)
That’s all I can think of right now, but sure I could come up with more if I had too.
I will say that I’ve been tempted before by these, but haven’t fell for them yet. But what tempted me when I can find such a good selection at the local Wal-Mart? The fact that some of these companies were offering me the opportunity to buy on pre-approved credit. Thankfully, my brain kicks in before I order!
October 2nd, 2008 at 6:01 pm
Exclusivity.
They are either selling a premium product, access to a product that isn’t available at ALL stores in ALL areas of the country (or their delivery area) or are really good at differnetiating themselves form the local green grocers or supermarket.
Repeat back end sales to boost the profit margins.
Integration into an exisitng logistics environemnt is probably helping also.
And economies fo scale. To make half a BILLION dollar a yea they must be selling an awful lot of apples.
Plus some people may be uder the impression that going to the store to select their own fruit is time consuming and worth the aded price.
Fiona Fell – The Profit Maximsing Web Geek
http:\\www.FionaFell.com.au
October 3rd, 2008 at 5:53 am
[...] Fruit by Mail: Why?… [...]
October 3rd, 2008 at 8:58 am
Because they make nice gifts. I’ve received two H&D fruit baskets. The fruit wasn’t anything different from what I’d get at the supermarket; however, the presentation was nice and the fruit itself was in superb condition given it had been shipped.
I’d send an H&D fruit gift if say someone I knew had purchased a new home and lived thousands of miles away from me.
October 3rd, 2008 at 12:53 pm
Does anyone know how much of their sales are gift orders, as opposed to people ordering for themselves? If it’s largely gifts, then in a sense, they’re not selling the fruit … they’re selling the packaging and shipping.
October 3rd, 2008 at 2:18 pm
Philip: that’s a great question. I would guess 75% gifts and 25% personal use. Why? For gifts, you are right: they are selling the packaging, shipping, and convenience. But the catalog copy and photos make the fruit look so luscious, many people also order for themselves. The copy and photography is so good, I often run out and buy pears — that’s how mouth-watering they look and sound!
October 7th, 2008 at 8:16 am
I think Sunnyland Farms, inc. (www.sunnylandfarmscom) says it best, in their catalog letter from Jane Willson, part founder of the company, when talking about their “FAMOUS-FOR-FLAVOR” Pecans. She says they’re “a bit better.” She goes on to explain, “We take a little more time buying and processing. And we try to serve our customers a little bit better.” Indeed, Sunnyland Farms ships “more boxes of pecans, other nuts and fruits by mail than anybody in the country.” Even Harry & David? (I confess, I’ve made it a holiday tradition to send my favorite clients Harry & David towers as gifts.) A different company, but the same idea of selling something by mail that, yes, you can get at the supermarket – but it’s just “a bit better.” Or perhaps Jane should say “a bite better!”
October 10th, 2008 at 10:43 am
Hi Bob,
I have a good client in Michigan who has provided a significant portion of my revenue over the last several years. I live in Florida, so two years ago for Christmas, I sent a case of oranges and a case of grapefruits to their office (from a mail-order fruit company here in the Sunshine State). I received the usual e-mails of appreciation sent in the holiday spirit. So last year, just to mix it up I decided to send them chocolate – not just any chocolate, but Mickey’s Chocolate from Disney World (not cheap either). While I did get a message or two of thanks, I did actually receive the same candid question from several in the office…Where’s the fruit???
Maybe Harry and David are on to something…
slr
October 12th, 2008 at 2:44 pm
It’s REALLY good fruit. My grandparents used to receive the Fruit of the Month club from a client each year. Each month we waited to see what delicious treat would be arriving. I don’t think Harry and David’s quality is quite as good as it used to be then – they’re so big now that it’s probably difficult to maintain that level of selectiveness. But they still offer a much better product than we can buy locally. Our grocery stores in the DC area have AWFUL produce. (Even Whole Foods’ produce is often mediocre – and they are the best in the area.) The Harry and David’s fruit seems to be picked closer to ripeness and arrives fresher. It’s definitely more flavorful than the tasteless, expensive stuff we have to choose from in our local stores.
October 14th, 2008 at 4:09 pm
I know the answer here – it’s “Not too much.” (!)
A colleague of my husband’s sent us a Harry & David gift basket last Christmas. Some fruit and some chocolates. Wonderful stuff. We ate it all up and wanted more.
So I got the catalog a month or so later, and ordered us a box of pears. Of the 10 pears, I think we ate 3.
The gift box had excellent quality stuff, and not too much of it.
(I hope his pal sends us another box this Christmas. Needless to say, I won’t bother to order more pears!)
October 21st, 2008 at 7:46 pm
Fruit gift baskets are perfect for birthdays, get well, or holidays, delighting all your recipient’s senses, from appearance and aroma to sound and taste. Nothing makes as dramatic a statement of how much you care then sending a fruit gift basket overflowing with large, unblemished, ripe fruit, complimented with award winning wines, gourmet cheeses, and irresistible chocolate covered dried fruits and nuts.
For detailed information about the online fruit gift basket companies, visit http://www.fruitbasketreview.com. Fruit Basket Review is dedicated to providing insider information about the online fruit gift basket industry and will help you find the highest quality gourmet fruit baskets at the best prices as well as provide you valuable discount coupon codes.
October 29th, 2008 at 11:41 pm
I used to work at H&D in Medford, Oregon packing those fruit baskets. The big secret is that the fruit is the same as the fruit you get in the stores. We workers were trained to pick out the ones without bruises and if there were bruises how to hide them from view.
My favorite thing to do while I worked there was to go shopping in the outlet store near the production factory. At the time I could not believe someone would pay such high prices for a pretty basket of colorful fruit. I think that the reason for the high sales is that the displays are very attractive. It isn’t that you get better fruit, it is just that the overall effect is delicious looking.
November 3rd, 2009 at 12:19 pm
Haven’t you noticed that the fruits purveyed by your local supermarket have absolutely no real flavor any more? I think it’s because the growers feed their trees and plants with petroleum-based fertilizers. Whatever the reason, H&D’s products always tasted far better and juicier than the A&P’s. Granted, I haven’t had any H&D lately but if they’re smart enough to make that much money, they’re probably smart enough to buy their products from organic growers, who rebuild the soil constantly, providing all the ingredients necessary to insure delicious produce. Anyone shopping for my Christmas present can send me the Fruit of the Month any time!
October 1st, 2011 at 9:36 am
Wine Glasses for birthday gifts…
[...]Fruit by Mail: Why? – bly.com blog – bly.com direct marketing blog[...]…