The Death of Craft

February 18th, 2005 by Bob Bly

We live in a society that, for the most part, seems to value speed, efficiency, service, economy, and technology over quality and craftsmanship.

Therefore, those who are true craftsmen or masters of a particular trade are rapidly becoming obsolete or unable to compete in business ? because consumers are not willing to pay a premium for the level of craftsmanship they bring to their product or service.

Example: a local resident in my county has spent his professional life becoming a master at tuning pianos by ear and hand.

But new technology allows far less skilled technicians to tune pianos adequately, using electronic monitors, faster and more efficiently ? and these untrained tuners charge much less.

Photography is another great example of ?the death of craft,? according to BD.

?I am a professional photographer,? says BD. ?I got my skills to a world-class level and realized that ? for the most part ? people no longer cared enough to support my business.?

He blames it, in part, on the frenzied pace of modern society: ?As you know, it follows that the fast pace erodes appreciation for craft in our young.

?If I could produce quality at the speed, price, and efficiency, I?m not sure the young buyers would recognize the quality of craft.?

Another example is graphic design ? and it?s a sad story.

In the early 1980s, when I was an advertising manager for a manufacturing company in New York City, I used SB, a freelance graphic artist, to design our sales brochures.

He was such a meticulous craftsman that, when he got galleys from the typesetter, he would literally cut the text apart word by word ? even letter by letter, at times ? to make it just right.

?Will anyone know the difference?? I asked him.

?I?ll know the difference,? SB replied.

But with the advent of desktop publishing, doing layouts manually faded away, and no one was willing to pay SB?s rates for his level of skill and caring. Clients wanted jobs delivered electronically as Mac files; no one wanted the old-fashioned boards that SB did by hand. And today SB is a doorman in New York City.

How about you? Are you a craftsperson? And do you ever worry about your craft dying out or being rendered obsolete by either technology or changing times?

This entry was posted on Friday, February 18th, 2005 at 8:15 am and is filed under General. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

110 responses about “The Death of Craft”

  1. Danny said:

    I try to be as much of a craftsman as pushy, impatient clients will allow. I take my work seriously and won’t “just throw something together real quick” for a client.

    I think the problem is more general, though. We’ve become a discount-instant-gratification society.

    People would rather have it done now, than done well. And this is as true of corporate executives determining the wages for desk clerks and sales associates as it is of consumers buying DIY particleboard furniture instead of heirloom pieces.

    We’re more “Wal-mart and McDonald’s” than “General Store and Sunday Dinner.” Welcome to the United States of Generica. No line, no waiting.

  2. reptile_k said:

    United States of Generica has its cultural roots, Paul Graham provided good observation in this article Made in USA
    ( http://www.changethis.com/12.MadeInUSA )

    Not appricating craftsmanship is not a bad thing, nor a good thing, it’s just the culture.

  3. Bruce DeBoer said:

    Thanks for posting this Bob. I want to throw another thought your way since you mentioned cutting type.

    Mediocrity emerged from the disappearance of typesetters because we could do it ourselves. “Good enough” is something easier said when accountability falls on us alone as it did once we could set our own type on the desktop. What we would have once returned to a typesetter because of poor quality, we may tend to accept if it was done on the desktop.

    This was my first recollection of the downturn in quality, but I’m sure there were earlier examples if I had paid attention.

    What do you suppose the future affect on society will be?

  4. Joel said:

    You might want to look at http://www.englishcut.com to see how a craftsman is doing very well these days making custom made suits for men. Craftsmanship must also go along with supply and demand. Those things that are in demand will sell. For example, the folks who sell Wisner (www.wisner.com) wooden view cameras had their best year, in spite of the fact that most people are turning to digital cameras. You can also get special edition (numbered) fountain pens for several thousands of dollars from the Fountain Pen Hospital (www.fountainpenhospital.com).

  5. Bruce DeBoer said:

    Joel,
    I think the point is that demand for craft is declining. Supply has outstripped demand for craft continually for the last 20 at least. Still, I too can sight countless examples of jawdropping craftsmanship in business. It’s the decline that concerns me.

    -bruce

  6. free pregnant porn gallery said:

    free pregnant porn gallery

    free pregnant porn gallery

  7. digital atomic clock said:

    digital atomic clock

    Research about digital atomic clock.

  8. bcwmdhvmpq said:

    Hello! Good Site! Thanks you! babddytntp

  9. free cartoon porn gifs said:

    free cartoon porn gifs

    free cartoon porn gifs

  10. fucking hairy pussy free trailers said:

    fucking hairy pussy free trailers

    fucking hairy pussy free trailers

  11. group intercourse said:

    group intercourse

    group intercourse

  12. black blowjob vids said:

    black blowjob vids

    black blowjob vids

  13. gay head big cock said:

    gay head big cock

    gay head big cock

  14. gay pornstar tommy cruise said:

    gay pornstar tommy cruise

    gay pornstar tommy cruise

  15. mexican mom porn said:

    mexican mom porn

    mexican mom porn

  16. Disney said:

    see adult cartoon pics

  17. www.blowjobpornpics.com said:

    I am just no longer specified exactly where you are taking your details, nevertheless good subject. I personally must spend an afternoon understanding a great deal more or maybe identifying extra. Thanks for excellent information and facts I had been hunting for this info for my objective.

  18. d3dx9_30.dll said:

    Howdy, There’s no doubt that your web site could possibly be having web browser compatibility issues. When I take a look at your site in Safari, it looks fine however, if opening in Internet Explorer, it has some overlapping issues. I simply wanted to provide you with a quick heads up! Aside from that, wonderful website!

  19. mjsmxmnft said:

    The Death of Craft – bly.com blog – bly.com direct marketing blog
    amjsmxmnft
    mjsmxmnft http://www.gxxx4e3s3ko937l34x5yp0d585a29tb9s.org/
    [url=http://www.gxxx4e3s3ko937l34x5yp0d585a29tb9s.org/]umjsmxmnft[/url]

  20. hoverboard new law ohio said:

    hoverboard new law ohio

  21. ?????? said:

    ????????????????????????????????????????????????????2012?????????????FDA????????????????????????????????????????????????762.??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????

  22. cheap jordans online said:

    Flurry of Air Jordan 13 Doernbecher Children’s Hospital charity bring color official image, as a new member of the Air Jordan 13 shoes are hot, overwhelmed join DB series, with exquisite details bring rich people never get tired of boutique feel .
    cheap jordans online

  23. cheap retro jordans said:

    With the debut of color Wing It, as well as a new color addition Air Jordan 2, this will be the exclusive Michael Jordan once the PE investment in commercially available color, with the familiar black and red Chicago Bulls presented atmosphere, creating this Air Jordan 2 Alternate 87.
    cheap retro jordans

  24. nba 2k16 mt cheat table said:

    You’re a very beneficial website; couldn’t make it without ya!|

  25. Cheap NFL Jerseys China said:

    The last 1 is what you think it is tually and yet, it is very porn site (. And that eh person is to agree to be a “BUILDER” with whatever nts, suggestions, thoughts and ideas they generate. Displays vary from product to product.ResSleep is a growing work of sleep clinics in Australia that provides premium patient services that include snoring cures, sleep tests, CPAP Mhines, CPAP Masks, sleep apnea test. Concrete, food mug to successfully dedicated home market achieve, increase present internet access.
    Cheap NFL Jerseys China

  26. hoverboard vinyl wrap said:

    hoverboard vinyl wrap zx6r

  27. hoverboard rules for illinois said:

    hoverboard rules for illinois

  28. nba scores said:

    Shop for NBA jerseys at the official NBA Store! We carry the widest variety of , and Replica NBA basketball jerseys online. Browse for your favorite team or player, for Hardwood NBA Jerseys, and youth sizes. Keep checking back for the arrivals of the NBA Nike Jersey!
    nba scores

  29. Cheap Soccer Jerseys said:

    v .Number of View :144Gone are the days where using a remote ant, understanding the channel change buttons plus the volu change, mute and energy buttons. Decide on this matter so that you will be able to move the table to the scope.Although a bit uneventful at tis, Celia’s life is pelling enough to bee invested in. You ought to be careful the noticeable different is not suspicious.
    Cheap Soccer Jerseys

  30. cheap air jordans said:

    Flurry of Air Jordan 13 Doernbecher Children’s Hospital charity bring color official image, as a new member of the Air Jordan 13 shoes are hot, overwhelmed join DB series, with exquisite details bring rich people never get tired of boutique feel .
    cheap air jordans

  31. Wholesale Jerseys said:

    There are a amount of nanny cams available that are as tiny as a power, as alternative caras may be hidden inside a pen.You need to sound for the location for the table in your household.April 4, 2014 at 5:11 PM RedPat said..youtube.
    Wholesale Jerseys

  32. ???? said:

    33???????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????4%?????????????4?????

  33. Fake Yeezys said:

    Figuring out where the cheapest coupons are these days is important in today’s economy. To really take full advantage of coupon collecting as a life-style, you have to take time to discover the the inner workings of this wonderful approach to shopping. The following article has the things you need to know.
    Fake Yeezys

  34. nba standings said:

    Shop for NBA jerseys at the official NBA Store! We carry the widest variety of , and Replica NBA basketball jerseys online. Browse for your favorite team or player, for NBA Jersey, and youth sizes. Keep checking back for the arrivals of the NBA Nike Jersey!
    nba standings

  35. hoverboard repair chicago jobs said:

    hoverboard repair number california

  36. Yeezy Replica said:

    Figuring out where the cheapest coupons are these days is important in today’s economy. To really take full advantage of coupon collecting as a life-style, you have to take time to discover the the inner workings of this wonderful approach to shopping. The following article has the things you need to know.
    Yeezy Replica

  37. hoverboard 6.5 inch rim said:

    hoverboard 6.5 inch rim

  38. nba jersey for sale said:

    Shop for NBA jerseys at the official NBA Store! We carry the widest variety of Jerseys Sale – Up To 70% Off Jerseys, and Replica NBA basketball jerseys online. Browse for your favorite team or player, for Swingman NBA Jerseys, and youth sizes. Keep checking back for the arrivals of the NBA Nike Jersey!
    nba jersey for sale

  39. hoverboard knockoff handbags said:

    hoverboard knockoff

  40. cheap jordans for sale said:

    As Air Jordan 12 series of the most classic color, following the return again in 2009 after the upper material and details or differ from 2009 models, and will not use nubuck leather uppers, but with the OG year version of the same leather material, disease face flag will not appear on the upper.
    cheap jordans for sale

  41. csgo skins bot said:

    }

  42. hoverboard rules abc said:

    hoverboard rules nsw

  43. ray ban clubmaster ii said:

    I like what you guys are usually up too. This type of clever work and coverage! Keep up the fantastic works guys I’ve included you guys to my personal blogroll.

  44. Cheap Jerseys From China said:

    For instance, we’ve got described a website {that is|that’s|which is|that is certainly|that is se model of HD. On the other hand, maybe they are into NASCAR.3. There are certain glasses that make ideal groomsman gifts: personalized glasses that can hold alcohol. You have a wide variety including double shot, highball, lowball, on the rocks, and beer glasses. It is about time now to start planning your summer retreat. SummaryOklahoma University has discovered innovative approach for online and offline classroom sessions to groom each student in a perfect way. Challenging both their minds and bodies in this serious art form, those who foremost in dance need all the help they can get. Nevertheless, the value in the process is challenged by two Danish scientists who reviewed the major clinical trials of screening mammography declared that five of the seven trials had been flawed which none shown that it saved lives.Lavish climax, pointless to say, software, this type of go walking upright vacuum cleaner, the main automatic robot are classified as the violin with regards to degree shown incredible rubbing guitar strings, ribbon proficiencies.
    Cheap Jerseys From China

  45. hoverboard 62 dollars said:

    hoverboard 62 dollars fast

  46. NBA Jersey said:

    Shop for NBA jerseys at the official NBA Store! We carry the widest variety of , and Replica NBA basketball jerseys online. Browse for your favorite team or player, for Hardwood NBA Jerseys, and youth sizes. Keep checking back for the arrivals of the NBA Nike Jersey!
    NBA Jersey

  47. kyrie 2 said:

    20160411Stephen curry, brave point guard, now is the NBA’s hottest star.[url=http://www.kobe11.org]kobe 11[/url] This season isn’t over, he has broken the three quarterly scoring record, a lot of goals for fans all exclamation “completely unreasonable”, “even the NBA game designers are a headache.
    kyrie 2

  48. nba 2k16 mt glitch january said:

    The posts is rather significant.|

  49. nike air max 1 essential sneakers said:

    I rarely write comments, but I browsed a few remarks on this page %BLOG_TITLE%. I do have a few questions for you if it’s okay. Could it be simply me or does it seem like a few of these responses look like they are coming from brain dead folks? 😛 And, if you are writing at additional places, I’d like to follow|keep up with} you. Would you list of the complete urls of your social sites like your linkedin profile, Facebook page or twitter feed?

  50. hoverboard rules starting january 1st tuesday said:

    hoverboard rules starting january 1st tuesday

  51. ?????? said:

    25???12?????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????

  52. prezzi oakley ray ban prezzi scontati said:

    When the weather cool downs may need ѕоmethіng tо throw on, maintain style wіth a jacket оr Paul Fredrick MenStyle. From hoodies to sports coats, casual tо formal, yоu will get a jacket for occasion at Moncler outlet, anу style and fоr any budget.

  53. hoverboard xl cheap price said:

    hoverboard xl cheap price

  54. hoverboard battery mah said:

    hoverboard battery connector

  55. michael kors canada said:

    Who couldn’t use help in this economy? Using coupons can be a way to make the most of your budget. Use everything that you read ahead to see what you can do to start saving money, that way you will be in a better financial position in the future.
    michael kors canada

  56. new hoverboard real or fake 105.7 said:

    new hoverboard real

  57. hoverboard new law in illinois alimony said:

    hoverboard new law in illinois alimony

  58. hoverboard cheap under 200 said:

    hoverboard cheap under 200

  59. ??????? said:

    ?????????????11?26???FDA???????????????????????????????????????????????????????????,?????????????????30%?”????????????????????????????????????”??????????????????”?

  60. kyrie 2 said:

    0414 In history, few people can change the sport of basketball, [url=http://www.stephencurryshoes.com]Stephen Curry Shoes[/url] you are the one of a handful of people, is just like my dream team teammate Byrd and Jordan had done the same.
    kyrie 2

  61. hoverboard battery mod said:

    hoverboard battery mod

  62. the hoverboard real said:

    hoverboard flying skateboard

  63. hoverboard new law in georgia marriage said:

    hoverboard new law nj points

  64. hoverboard and skateboard 3d said:

    hoverboard and scooter laws 150cc

  65. hoverboard 2016 toys r us said:

    hoverboard 2016 3v

  66. mattel hoverboard cost said:

    mattel hoverboard cost

  67. hoverboard usa for sale said:

    neolev hoverboard with 6 base (blue)

  68. hoverboard zoomed out synonym said:

    hoverboard zoomed out map

  69. hoverboard laws queensland said:

    hoverboard laws florida breaks

  70. hoverboard 7 news 4pm said:

    hoverboard 7 inch wheels lotus

  71. csgo skins ebay said:

    I appreciate the information on your web sites. Much thanks!|

  72. hoverboard for sale in malaysia said:

    hoverboard for kids

  73. occhiali da vista oakley crosslink ray ban bausch & lomb said:

    Your bridge hand is the onе in the neighborhood . opposite the onе which уоu uѕе to secure the stick, and it’ll make а cupped contour around support іt whеn you visit strike. Within your stance, your legs should make а tripod with a bridge kids finger.

  74. oakley antix polarized replacement lens mount said:

    I were once recommended this site via your cousin. I’m now not sure with certainty if this present is written as a result of him as use of else realise such several approximately your trouble. You could be incredible! Regards!
    oakley antix polarized replacement lens mount

  75. hoverboard new laws in california unmarried said:

    hoverboard new york ny zip

  76. ray ban glasses frame uk said:

    I love your blog.. very nice colors & theme. Did you create this website yourself or did you hire someone to do it for you? Plz reply as I’m looking to design my own blog and would like to find out where u got this from. appreciate it

  77. ??? said:

    Is that true? Ill spread this information. Anyway, nice posting.
    ???

  78. Cheap NFL Jerseys China said:

    Get groups to agree and docunt what they will agree to STOP, START and CONTINUE bk in the team workple in order to build better trust, teamwork, happiness and performance. Nurology wasn’t just chosen by initial psychics however, even historic mathematicians plus philosophers.Get groups to agree and docunt what they will agree to STOP, START and CONTINUE bk in the team workple in order to build better trust, teamwork, happiness and performance. Regular and clear munication is important. A five-day annual holiday marks the charm and excitement of Durga Puja, that extends for a span of five days popularly known as Sasti, Saptami, Aastami, Nabami and Dashami.
    Cheap NFL Jerseys China

  79. michael kors canada said:

    The use of coupons is getting more and more popular these days. There are “coupon queens”, Internet sites and television shows that all claim to have gotten things for free because of their couponing. They make it sound so easy but it does take a bit of effort and organization. The tips in this article can provide you with the secrets of couponing so you are able to secure your own savings.
    michael kors canada

  80. hoverboard repair orlando reviews said:

    hoverboard repair orlando reviews

  81. Classic NBA Jerseys said:

    Shop for NBA jerseys at the official NBA Store! We carry the widest variety of , and Replica NBA basketball jerseys online. Browse for your favorite team or player, for Swingman NBA Jerseys, and youth sizes. Keep checking back for the arrivals of the NBA Nike Jersey!
    Classic NBA Jerseys

  82. NBA Jersey said:

    Shop for NBA jerseys at the official NBA Store! We carry the widest variety of NBA Jersey Outlet, and Replica NBA basketball jerseys online. Browse for your favorite team or player, for Retro NBA Jerseys, and youth sizes. Keep checking back for the arrivals of the NBA Nike Jersey!
    NBA Jersey

  83. hoverboard not working properly installed said:

    hoverboard not working properly hp

  84. nike air max 87 discount said:

    Hmm is anyone else encountering problems with the images on this blog loading? I’m trying to determine if its a problem on my end or if it’s the blog. Any feedback would be greatly appreciated.

  85. ray ban clubmaster misure oakley running said:

    Moncler is reаlly a hot shopping top which talked аnywhеrе аnd anytime fоr itѕ classical design and the beѕt quality. Most оf us for instance moncler coats men jackets,Moncler women jackets,moncler outlet kids jackets aѕ fine. Recently years winter haѕ brought uѕ an exceptionally hard time, becаusе thе temperature is receiving colder than before. So for thе producers, make their ski wear be protective while thе users warm is often a tough quandary. This romantic winter yоu would be the focus of fashion! The latest Moncler clothes wіll rеallу give which you big surprise thiѕ spring. Basing оn thе aim of favor and good design, Moncler haѕ released sо manу attractive and impressive activly works to us. For a fan оf Moncler, you shouldn’t havе missed аll its clothing.

  86. cheap oakleys said:

    I take pleasure in, cause I found just what I was having a look for. You’ve ended my 4 day long hunt! God Bless you man. Have a great day. Bye|

  87. ??? said:

    hi
    that’s good posting.
    ???

  88. hoverboard new york city ban kald?rma said:

    hoverboard new york yankees

  89. hoverboard vine videos said:

    hoverboard vine videos

  90. hoverboard real lexus dealer said:

    hoverboard real lexus of

  91. hoverboard catching fire in mall said:

    hoverboard catching fire in mall

  92. hoverboard caught on fire lyrics said:

    hoverboard caught on fire lyrics

  93. ??? said:

    hi
    that’s nice posting.
    ???

  94. Cheap Jerseys Wholesale said:

    . The stage was so distant that one could only see the figures moving around on stage.While many clients may ask models to pose topless or nude, several are just trying to find sobody to chat with.Get groups to agree and docunt what they will agree to STOP, START and CONTINUE bk in the team workple in order to build better trust, teamwork, happiness and performance.k.
    Cheap Jerseys Wholesale

  95. hoverboard repair orlando fl weather said:

    hoverboard repair nyc

  96. hoverboard rules as of jan 1 crossword said:

    hoverboard rules as of jan 1 crossword

  97. asics men's gel-cirrus33 running shoes reviews mens said:

    Its along the lines of you gain knowledge of my spirit! You often grasp such a lot of approximately this unique, like most people wrote typically the guide in the basket or a specific thing. I feel that you really could can with numerous percent towards force typically the message house a little, however other than that, this is fabulous blog. An ideal read. I’ll positively be spine.
    asics men’s gel-cirrus33 running shoes reviews mens

  98. michael kors canada said:

    Many people are advocating the usefulness of coupons. There are websites dedicated to the practice of couponing, and coupon experts eager to initiate you into the fold. Like anything that’s worth doing, though, getting the most out coupons requires a little bit of planning and work. This article will assist you if you wish to save money with coupons.
    michael kors canada

  99. ray ban rb 5228 ray ban graduati said:

    I hear you, just how much muсh does it cost to order а Moncler shoe? Like Moncler jackets thаt you purchase from Moncler, yоu are talking аbоut purchasing a quality product. Sufficient reason for purchasing high quality product you wіll wаnt to spend a littlе more thаn just goіng right down to a store like Payless or a mid-range priced store likе Dillards. Moncler shoes uѕuallу range in price from $100 tо $300 greenbacks. This iѕ uѕuаlly for а pump or a sandal оr wedge. But rather іf your lоokіng at purchasing а boot you’ll be forking ovеr bеtweеn $200 аnd $500 dollars depending on style.

  100. hoverboard really flies x files said:

    hoverboard really cheap yarn

  101. curry shoes said:

    0414 Farewell, Bryant could usher in a new career with the lakers [url=http://www.stephencurryshoes.com]Stephen Curry Shoes[/url] legends in the history of the “magic” Johnson published a “dear kobe” letter, to pay tribute to Bryant’s great career.At the end of the letter, the magician also labeled as he and kobe Bryant’s intimate photos.
    curry shoes

  102. kevin durant shoes said:

    20160411 Treasury said, “warriors is not invincible,[url=http://www.officialkdshoes.com]kd shoes[/url] we have to concentrate in the remaining four games [url=http://www.kobe11.org]kobe 11[/url] play 48 minutes, rather than only to win, the key lies in the way we play and input, we should put the focus back, fully engaged in the game.”
    kevin durant shoes

  103. self wheel scooter said:

    Sometimes Forty working hours a single week found on farm of Ky, This breadmaker those self wheel scooter in the slide and therefore donned them all the way through water, sleet, glaciers, appear to be, along with other things you might consider find out for the spheres. They held up Impressive and additionally could’ve been interesting entire period of time, to go over We read could be that the dog’s fur located on the calcaneus or heel put on out and about quickly (consequence decreasing these folks on and off), and also the sec set begun flow a smaller, that happen to be stationary via skin protectant. I i am full of pride to get saved all of [$], due to I’ve got to admit who great cruel the winter appears to be considerably more beautiful after the little tootsies remained at just perfectly clothing.

  104. Takako Golab said:

    How does Computer Ram memory make a pc faster and deliver better performance?

  105. faidah pohon pisang said:

    I have been provided a Dell computer from my sis. However , her former spouse set up his accounts on this computer (says he cannot keep in mind the password), making himself the only administrator. Today, I cannot add any applications ( like iTunes), neither can I delete anything. How can I clear his passwords from this computer, and make me the supervisor? I are afraid which i shall have to delete everything, then start again (ugh! ) That could mean buying new applications, installing all of them and so on. Any kind of ideas?.

  106. model jilbab untuk kebaya said:

    How can I make a individualized banner to get a blogspot blog?

  107. catering jakarta said:

    I have an idea to get a really good internet site but have never started a website before, so I don’t know where to start..

  108. nasi kotak jakarta said:

    Uncertain of Copyright insurance policies from sites that let you ‘digg’ content articles?

  109. sayanda said:

    Make sure you, I just like to possess answer from articles expert/s. -Can you get penalized in search engines for submitting the same articles to multiple content submmision websites?. -What must i do to claim the copyright of my article/s? Should I post it on my internet site first before post it to the people websites? Will search engines consider the article content material as duplicated?. Thanks number in advance!.

  110. KTI kebidanan Tentang Kehamilan said:

    may i protect my blog content material copyright without registering it to copyright departmen? make sure you help?

Leave a Reply