What”s a Critic to Do?

January 7th, 2008 by Bob Bly

Playwright Edward Albee, author of “Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf,” has some harsh criticism for critics.

“Some critics cater to existing taste,” says Albee. “What they should be doing is trying to improve it.”

It seems to me that opinions as to the function of critics vary, and there are basically 3 schools of thought as to what a critic should do:

A) Let you know what he, the critic, thought of the movie, play, book, or record.

B) Help you determine whether you’d like it and should spend your time and money to read, see, or hear it.

C) Help you improve your tastes so you CAN enjoy a higher level of art (as Albee seems to think).

Which do you think is the critic’s role — A, B, C, or something completely different? And why?

This entry was posted on Monday, January 7th, 2008 at 10:22 am and is filed under General. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

42 responses about “What”s a Critic to Do?”

  1. Kevin said:

    I believe the critic ought to elaborate on why he or she liked or disliked the piece in question and try to educate the reader of the critique to elevate the reader’s knowledge. This way, the reader may judge the critic’s expertise and whether the critique is credible, as well as whether to spend money and time on the specific entertainment. In this way, all three objectives might be achieved.

  2. Kristi Holl said:

    I think a good critic accomplishes all three objectives, at least most of the time. I have found, though, that I have to find (usually by trial and error) the critics that I most often agree with before I will spend money to see what they recommend. Tastes vary so much. There are certain critics who recommend books and movies, and I know I will love them too. Other critics will recommend books and movies with a 5 Star rating, and I nearly always hate what they’ve chosen. I’ve learned which critics I can trust to steer me to things I will personally enjoy.

  3. Joel Heffner said:

    According to the dictionary a critic is “a person who expresses an unfavorable opinion of something.” My own thought is that a critic is meant to be interesting so that folks will want to read the newspaper or view the TV review.

  4. Stacey Mathis, Copywriter for the Parent Market said:

    I think a critic’s job is to (a) analyze and interpret so that we have more insight, and (b) be a filtering mechanism, merely b/c most people don’t have unlimited money, time and energy to see, read, eat and imbibe EVERYTHING and visit EVERYWHERE.

  5. Lori said:

    Frankly, I think a critic should do all three. I think there’s a fine line they walk, however, between what they want to say and what sells in the media. I’ve never been a fan of pandering to numbers and ratings, yet isn’t that how critics gain their celebrity – through that very controversy that sells?

    I think Tess Gerritsen (http://tessgerritsen.com/blog) has a handle on it. She posted a quote this week on her blog about critics, which I think every struggling writer should keep in mind.

  6. Tracey Minella, Copywriter said:

    Having previously written a restaurant review column for three years on Long Island, I think A and B are a critic’s job. If C results from it, all the better. But taste is so personal. Who is to say that anyone’s taste needs to be “improved”?

    My job was to give you the information and my opinion, but only you can decide if the place suits your current taste–or if it sounds like something different you may want to try.

    I think critics need to be credible. For example, I never reviewed a seafood place because I don’t like seafood. To have done so would have been inappropriate.

    If a credible critic delivers enough detail in an entertaining way, readers can make an informed decision. (And, by the way, “Two Thumbs Up–Way Up!” is NOT sufficient!)

    Why can’t that chicken and ribs lover just enjoy his meal without someone trying to get him to eat caviar?

  7. Lou Wasser said:

    Here’s a cautionary tale about critics.

    Two years ago, my friend Fred and I had just finished our fifth class in an advanced screenwriting course offered by a noted Hollywood screenwriter at UCLA Extension.

    In keeping with our weekly routine, I was all set to drive Fred home. But he was so excited by the encouragement our instructor had given him about his screenplay (a thriller set in Europe), he insisted on first stopping for a celebratory drink at a local bar.

    I had to get up the next morning, and since I don’t drink and drive,I begged off.

    Unfortunately, the night didn’t end too well for Fred. He called the next morning to tell me that, upon leaving the bar, he was held up at gunpoint.

    The robber had demanded Fred’s wallet as well as all the cash he had on him.

    The robber then looked at the briefcase Fred was carrying, and asked him what was in it.

    “Please don’t take that,” Fred begged. “It can’t possibly be of any use to you. The only thing in that briefcase is a screenplay I wrote for a class at UCLA. And my computer just crashed after I printed it out. It may be the only copy I have.”

    “I’ll take the briefcase too,” said the robber.

    Although Fred felt lucky to get away with his life, he was mortified over the probable loss of one full year’s creative work.

    Needless to say, the police were unable to help him.

    About a month later, Fred called me to tell me the very unusual end to this story.

    He had just that morning received a package in the mail with no return address. The package contained the screenplay that was stolen from him. (Obviously there was no money, credit cards or wallet in the package).

    As he thumbed through the screenplay, Fred noticed some unusual things. Some of the pages were bent at the corner, others were paper-clipped, and yet others bore what seemed to be coffee stains.

    Whoever stole his screenplay that fateful night seemed to have taken the trouble to read it.

    And here’s the amazing thing. About five pages into the screenplay, there began a series of red-penciled comments — comments which appeared throughout the entire work.

    “Delete this scene,” “unrealistic dialogue,” “more motivation needed here,” “this character needs more development…,” etc.

    Fred was appalled. Then after I calmed him down, I even persuaded him to feel a bit amused.

    Why, we both wondered, would a common thief go to this trouble?

    Together we reasoned through the entire series of events step by step.

    Here’s the best explanation we came up with:


  8. Perry Leimkuhler said:

    I like the helpful information you provide in your articles. I’ll bookmark your blog and check again here regularly. I’m quite certain I’ll learn many new stuff right here! Good luck for the next!

  9. http://cz.iacaiberry.info said:

    Thankyou for helping out, great information.

  10. Full Article said:

    This website certainly has all the information I wanted concerning this subject and didn’t know who to ask.

  11. mark photo said:

    oGH6Il Keep up the great work , I read few content on this site and I believe that your site is very interesting and contains sets of fantastic information.

  12. www.letmetellyouaboutbeer.com said:

    After I originally commented I seem to have clicked the -Notify me when new comments are added- checkbox and now every time a comment is added I receive 4 emails with the exact same comment. Is there an easy method you can remove me from that service? Many thanks!

  13. http://es.iacaiberry.info said:

    Nice blog here! Also your website loads up fast! What host are you using? Can I get your affiliate link to your host? I wish my website loaded up as quickly as yours lol

  14. Bee Coins said:

    I simply wished to appreciate you all over again. I’m not certain the things I would have achieved without the type of smart ideas documented by you concerning this situation. It actually was the alarming matter in my opinion, however , coming across the professional strategy you handled the issue took me to jump for fulfillment. I’m thankful for your service as well as sincerely hope you find out what a powerful job you have been putting in educating other individuals thru a blog. I am certain you haven’t met all of us.

  15. http://it.iacaiberry.info said:

    Simply a smiling visitant here to share the love (:, btw outstanding style. “He profits most who serves best.” by Arthur F. Sheldon.

  16. get instagram likes without tags said:

    If you wish for to increase your familiarity only keep visiting this web site and be updated with the most up-to-date information posted

  17. Sylvie Zobel said:

    I truly appreciate this post. I’ve been looking all over for this! Thank goodness I found it on Bing. You have made my day! Thanks again!

  18. http://fr.muscleview.info said:

    I must show my thanks to you for rescuing me from this scenario. Just after scouting throughout the world-wide-web and meeting concepts which were not productive, I assumed my entire life was well over. Existing minus the answers to the issues you’ve fixed by means of your post is a serious case, as well as ones which may have in a negative way damaged my entire career if I had not discovered your blog post. Your own personal skills and kindness in dealing with all the details was vital. I am not sure what I would’ve done if I hadn’t encountered such a stuff like this. It’s possible to at this time relish my future. Thanks so much for this reliable and result oriented guide. I won’t be reluctant to propose the sites to anyone who wants and needs recommendations on this subject matter.

  19. escape room bucuresti said:

    Pretty section of content. I just stumbled upon your web site and in accession capital to assert that I get actually enjoyed account your blog posts. Any way I will be subscribing to your feeds and even I achievement you access consistently fast.

  20. Maria said:

    It wasn’t simply a matter of combining styles it also involved creativity.

    The US Congress and the United States Senate recognized his achievements.
    The best is that you can even go for headlines of the day and make you fully

  21. nike sneakers for men said:

    nike sneakers for men

    Item: 624041-604

  22. link said:

    It’s nearly impossible to find well-informed people in this particular topic, but you sound like you know what you’re talking about! Thanks

  23. Hitech Australia said:

    I needed to thank you for this good read!! I absolutely enjoyed every little bit of it. I have got you book-marked to look at new things you post…

  24. gry internetowe online said:

    Hi there very nice website!! Guy .. Excellent .. Amazing .. I will bookmark your web site and take the feeds also…I am satisfied to search out numerous useful information right here in the post, we’d like develop extra strategies on this regard, thanks for sharing.

  25. delhitechforum.com said:

    Good post. I learn something new and challenging on blogs I stumbleupon everyday. It will always be exciting to read through articles from other writers and use a little something from other web sites.

  26. delhitechforum.com said:

    Way cool! Some extremely valid points! I appreciate you penning this post and the rest of the site is very good.

  27. http://it.muscleview.info said:

    I truly enjoy examining on this site, it has fantastic articles . “Violence commands both literature and life, and violence is always crude and distorted.” by Ellen Glasgow.

  28. http://ccube.info said:

    My brother recommended I might like this website. He was entirely right. This post actually made my day. You can not imagine just how much time I had spent for this info! Thanks!

  29. Horace Rayner said:

    I like to browse around the online world, regularly I will just go to Stumble Upon and read and check stuff out.

  30. http://ccube.info said:

    I’ve been browsing online greater than 3 hours lately, but I by no means discovered any fascinating article like yours. It’s beautiful price sufficient for me. In my opinion, if all website owners and bloggers made good content material as you did, the net can be a lot more helpful than ever before. “When there is a lack of honor in government, the morals of the whole people are poisoned.” by Herbert Clark Hoover.

  31. http://miricoperu.info said:

    Some really fantastic info , Gladiolus I noticed this. “Children require guidance and sympathy far more than instruction.” by Ambrose Gwinett Bierce.

  32. http://pl.miricoperu.info said:

    Hello my loved one! I wish to say that this post is amazing, nice written and come with approximately all significant infos. I’d like to see extra posts like this.

  33. http://cz.miricoperu.info said:

    you’re in point of fact a excellent webmaster. The web site loading velocity is incredible. It sort of feels that you’re doing any distinctive trick. Moreover, The contents are masterwork. you have performed a great activity in this matter!

  34. Francine Milroy said:

    Calgary Bus Rental

  35. mac eyeshadow humid New GbdAKj6O2I said:

    mac vex eyeshadow Full Styles SoqQveT8nG | Caminhos da ?ndia
    mac eyeshadow humid New GbdAKj6O2I http://forextactics.com/mac-eyeshadow-humid-new-gbdakj6o2i/

  36. http://se.miricoperu.info said:

    You can certainly see your skills within the work you write. The arena hopes for even more passionate writers such as you who are not afraid to mention how they believe. All the time follow your heart. “There are only two industries that refer to their customers as users.” by Edward Tufte.

  37. Elizebeth Granvold said:

    I used to be suggested this web site by way of my cousin. I’m now not sure whether this post is written through him as no one else realize such specified about my problem. You are amazing! Thank you!

  38. What said:

    Kaye Fredlund


  39. mac foundation nw25 Harvest Of Values 5RoQDTmEG8 - said:

    ??resh brew mac lipstick Super Cheap With Free Shipping c8qtlsH1kL??Eastlocal Marketing Group on Shanghai of China
    mac foundation nw25 Harvest Of Values 5RoQDTmEG8 – http://baamboo.vn/mac-foundation-nw25-harvest-of-values-5roqdtmeg8/

  40. Santo Sheasby said:

    Just wanna input that you have a very nice web site , I the design and style it actually stands out.

  41. mac studio fix nc25 Strong Packing E9yGmXMsim - Fiwave said:

    snob by mac lipstick Free Shipping On Sale klqUIfBAyq – Mikels Wig Boutique Mikels Wig Boutique
    mac studio fix nc25 Strong Packing E9yGmXMsim – Fiwave http://fiwave.com/?p=1322

  42. http://nl.miricoperu.info said:

    I haven’t checked in here for a while because I thought it was getting boring, but the last several posts are great quality so I guess I’ll add you back to my everyday bloglist. You deserve it my friend :)

Leave a Reply