The $45 Question: What’s Your Online Marketing ROI?

August 20th, 2009 by Bob Bly

What’s the ROI for your favorite online marketing medium?

My favorite is e-mail marketing.

According to “Taking Names,” a special report from Direct magazine, in 2008 e-mail generated slightly more than $45 in revenues for every dollar spent on e-mail marketing.

I believe this number, because I know myself how to measure revenues from e-mail marketing precisely, so ROI can be tracked to the penny.

(My e-mail ROI is about $75 for every dollar spent on e-mail marketing.)

In addition to e-mail marketing, I also do other marketing activities.

We do a little PPC, and I can also track the revenues generated by Google Adwords precisely down to the penny.

I am also on Twitter and Facebook, but I do not know how to track revenues generated by either or even if they make me any money at all.

Perhaps there are analytics tools for social networking out there that I am just not aware of, and if you can point me toward them, you will have my thanks.

If you cannot track revenues generated by social networking, then I would argue that you cannot reliably and accurately calculate ROI, right?

That being the case, if you are one of the many raving social media fans trying to convince me of its incredible value — why?

Lord Kelvin, the British scientist, said: “If you can measure something in numbers, then you know something about it.”

Conversely, Kelvin’s statement implies that if you cannot measure something in numbers, than you do NOT know much about it.

I am pretty much in agreement with Kelvin. What about you?

Share

This entry was posted on Thursday, August 20th, 2009 at 11:00 am and is filed under Online Marketing. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

27 responses about “The $45 Question: What’s Your Online Marketing ROI?”

  1. Annarogers said:

    I’m glad to have visited your blog and good to know you! I find it interesting and informative.

  2. Lou Wasser said:

    What you’re posting here, Bob, makes pre-eminent sense to me. On a strict ROI basis though, what is traditionally known as “image advertising” makes absolutely no sense, since returns for such advertising are not measurable.

    I realize that direct marketers don’t do image advertising, but many large corporations do.

    Are you suggesting that the Coca Cola’s “teach-the-world-to sing” commercial and the “responsible environment corporate citizen” ads by oil companies are simply blowing dust in the wind?

    And what about a recent full-page back cover ad by a new bank called “Ally” in The New Yorker which reads: “We make money with you, not off you?”

    Was the bank throwing its money away with that one?

  3. What’s The Difference Between Spanish Style Interiors And Mexican Style Interiors? | GoogleTrends.US said:

    [...] The $45 Question: What's Your Online Marketing ROI? – bly.com blog … [...]

  4. Bob Bly said:

    I don’t know whether Coke or the NYC bank are making money from those ad campaigns, and they don’t, either. They are large businesses that can survive even if they spent money on advertising that doesn’t sell (definition of an ad that doesn’t sell: “brand advertisement”). Most small businesses cannot afford this.

  5. What Is The Difference Between Fashion Marketing And Fashion Merchandising? | GoogleTrends.US said:

    [...] The $45 Question: What's Your Online Marketing ROI? – bly.com blog … [...]

  6. Making Money Articles said:

    [...] Read more from the original source: The $45 Question: What’s Your Online Marketing ROI? [...]

  7. The $45 Question: What's Your Online Marketing ROI? - bly.com blog … « Marketing Direct said:

    [...] See the rest here: T­he $45 Quest­io­­n: W­ha­t­'s Yo­­ur O­&#173… [...]

  8. The $45 Question: What's Your Online Marketing ROI? - bly.com blog … said:

    [...] More: The $45 Question: What's Your Online Marketing ROI? – bly.com blog … [...]

  9. What’s My Credit Score? | Bad Credit Loans Reviews said:

    [...] The $45 Question: What's Your Online Marketing ROI? – bly.com blog … [...]

  10. Dianna Huff said:

    Bob, I don’t make money off of every thing I do, either i.e. — should I not go to networking meetings because I don’t come back with three projects in my hip pocket?

    Here is a blog post I wrote on this topic — which was actually in response to another post you did on this very topic:
    http://marcom-writer-blog.com/2009/03/26/social-media-dont-expect-a-marriage-proposal-on-the-first-date/

  11. Lou Wasser said:

    Diana:

    As long as Lord Kelvin’s ghost doesn’t show up at one of your networking meetings, you’ll be fine.

    Seriously, I think Bob was proposing a strict ROI or numerical accountability for advertising, not networking activities. That said, it seems to me that social media could be best viewed as extensions of in-person networking. Though Bob’s ultimate logic about the numbers issue is unassailable, I don’t see why he feels that twitter, facebook and the like are TOTAL wastes.

  12. Bob Bly said:

    Dianna: You miss the point. I do things without directly measureable ROI, too. But I do NOT — unlike the new media evangelist and social networking gurus — tell people that I know for a fact THEY should be doing them, too.

  13. Phil Wrzesinski said:

    Bob, I do “brand awareness” advertising constantly. In fact, it’s the primary focus of my advertising. So far I have found two ways to track ROI on such campaigns.

    The first is top-of-mind-awareness. We use a local college statistics class to do a survey where they ask people to “name all the stores in Jackson that sell toys”. This unaided recall gives us an idea not only of how many people think of us but also how many think of our competitors. Prior to starting the brand campaign, our unaided recall was 61%. After two years of “branding” our unaided recall went up to 78%. In our 4th year of branding our single, independent store now rivals Toys R Us and Wal-Mart in terms of unaided recall. (And we sell more toys per year than our local Wal-Mart and almost equal to Toys R Us).

    The second way to track the effect is traffic. Is it going up or down? Fortunately for us, traffic is going up (in spite of the economy here in Michigan and the 15.5% unemployment locally).

    Of course, you have to add in factors such as how well we perform in the store, if we have the right products at the right times for the right prices and all the other factors that influence word-of-mouth and repeat business, but I can emphatically say “branding” works for us.

    As for social media, I use FB to reinforce the brand image and communicate to our fans. I consider that part of our “brand campaign”, but not the whole campaign. Our email newsletters accomplish the same purpose. But radio takes up the bulk of our budget and works fantastically well now that we know how to do it right.

  14. Bob Bly said:

    Phil: Have you read Murray Raphel? He also specializes in retail marketing, but unlike you, focuses on direct marketing — not branding. You may find some of his methods and case studies to be of interest.

  15. Management Measures | Chris Greaves said:

    [...] am reminded of this by Bob Bly’s blog today, he writes in [...]

  16. Management Measures – Home Page said:

    [...] am reminded of this by Bob Bly’s blog today, he writes in [...]

  17. uggs said:

    Hi buddy, your blog??????s design needn’t be hard and clean and i love it. Your web site posts are superb. Please keep them coming. Greets!!!

  18. cancun barcelo said:

    Helpful, for the point and nicely written, some uncomplicated adjectives I would prefer to use to illustrate this wonderfully written piece of details.

  19. Aderson totesi. said:

    Thank you a lot for giving everyone an extraordinarily superb opportunity to read articles and blog posts from this blog. It is always very fantastic and also stuffed with a great time for me and my office fellow workers to search the blog really three times every week to find out the latest things you will have. Of course, I’m so certainly satisfied for the spectacular techniques you serve. Some 2 ideas in this post are rather the best we have had.

  20. joomla templates said:

    I like this website its a master peace ! Glad I found this on google. “The definition of a beautiful woman is one who loves me.” by Sloan Wilson.

  21. Rigoberto Boldery said:

    I just added this page to my favorites. I enjoy reading your posts. Tyvm!

  22. Dusty Thews said:

    I think you’ve got a lot of readers that are more than thankful to you and really pleased with the content on your blog, making me fantastically interested in what post will be next and about. High Waist Shorts

  23. ?????? google glass ? ?????? said:

    ?? ????? ????????? ????? ????? ???? Google Glass, ????????????? ??????????? Gooigle Inc..
    ??????? ?? ???????, ?????? ??? ??? ????????????????? ????????? ??? ??????????, ? ?? ??????????? ? ????? ?????
    ??????? ? ?????????? ??????????.
    ??? ???? ???????? ?????????? ???????? ?
    ?????? ??????? ????? ? ?????????? ????????????, ??????? ?????????? ????? ?????????? 720p.
    ???????? ??? ????? ???? Google Glass,
    ??? ????? ?????????? OS Android

  24. Maya said:

    What’s up i am kavin, its my first time to commenting anywhere,
    wwhen i read this piece off writing i thought i could also make comment due to this brilliant post.

  25. interstate moving truck rental quotes said:

    Envision him happy and fulfilled experiencing with his team a victory this
    Sunday. Generally, two types of storage facilities available for you,
    which are self storage and mobile storage. Our company knows for installing and using the best parts
    of auto. This is to indicate all kinds of defects regardless of how simple or complex they are; way before the defects result
    into serious problem. The rides include Hoodoo Run, Woo – Hoo
    Falls, Stingray Falls, Kiwi Curl, and more.
    People are advised to invest time to shop around different hardware stores.
    Internet speed at Symphony is many times your present speed and also
    you can download and upload your video easily.
    Systems Administrator career opportunities along with technology Jobs and career are admirable for
    well-known image in the field of business. The units send to
    the client are taken back to the location where the containers are kept in secured environment.
    Human resources is a large, varying discipline so
    it stands to reason that many who come into the field come from
    varied background.

  26. lange kleider said:

    Howdy, You will have completed an admirable job. I most certainly will unquestionably delicious that as well as privately suggest for you to my friends. I am certain will have them took advantage of this excellent website lange kleider.

  27. My Internet Marketing Corner said:

    I have to say Bob email marketing just doesn’t cut it for me! I think its become out dated by now, to much spam going around these days!

    I personally like Social Marketing, it just works for me!

Leave a Reply