Bob Bly Direct Response Copywriter Official Banner

GM Says “No Thanks” to Facebook Advertising

May 24th, 2012 by Bob Bly

Stephen Booser sent me an e-mail today in which he notes that GM has pulled its advertising program out of Facebook due to lack of results.

“Could this be the beginning of a realization by those who have things to sell that they have been sold a bill of goods by the young marketers most of whom, it seems to me, have never asked a closing question in their lives?” he asks rhetorically.

He suggests that “social” is not a synonym for “sell.” I believe the trendy marketing imperative of “having a conversation” is not the same as “selling  a product.” In fact, having a conversation may be the fall-back position for those marketers who don’t know how to sell.

Your thoughts?

Share

This entry was posted on Thursday, May 24th, 2012 at 10:01 am and is filed under General. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

65 responses about “GM Says “No Thanks” to Facebook Advertising”

  1. Giles Scott said:

    Hear, hear Bob. At last someone’s had the guts to point out the emperor is mightily underdressed…

  2. Ivan Walsh said:

    or maybe GM’s marketing team is incompetent re social media. It works for others.

  3. mature sexy women said:

    mature sexy women…

    […]GM Says “No Thanks” to Facebook Advertising – bly.com blog – bly.com direct marketing blog[…]…

  4. baking supplies said:

    baking supplies…

    […]GM Says “No Thanks” to Facebook Advertising – bly.com blog – bly.com direct marketing blog[…]…

  5. peopleinorganisationsjcu said:

    Check this out…

    […] that is the end of this article. Here you’ll find some sites that we think you’ll appreciate, just click the links over[…]……

  6. Bob Bly said:

    Ivan: Who does it work for? What are their sales from it?

  7. Brian Croner said:

    Getting “Likes” and giving away freebies doesn’t pay the bills. Did I just repeat myself from another post?

  8. Brian Croner said:

    And I might also add: You can talk yourself right out of a sale. I’ve seen poor sales people do it all the time.

    This hip notion that “having a conversation” just wastes a prospects valuable time. So much for Social Media being a marketing mechanism.

  9. GM Says “No Thanks” to Facebook Advertising – bly.com blog – bly.com | Joseph R Benson said:

    […] GM Says “No Thanks” to Facebook Advertising – bly.com blog – bly.com direct marketin…. Share this:PrintEmailFacebookDigg This entry was posted in News by Joseph Benson. Bookmark the permalink. […]

  10. Dirad Pte Ltd said:

    Introduce new product with attractive ad in FB captures the attention of most of the users, in that sense Facebook advertisement is good.

  11. Jim said:

    I don’t blame them at all. Facebook is a testy media. Most of the people on it are not necessarily the people who are looking for new cars. Cars sales are pushed through word of mouth more than anything. I personally own Subarus and will talk them up until I’m blue in the face. Conversely I’ve owned two fords and I will never purchase them again and if asked I will tell anyone why I wouldn’t purchase them again. I feel car sales are a personal experience type of sale and no amount of facebook likes or updates are going to ever beat word of mouth references and test drives. Facebook marketing isn’t for everyone.

  12. lovely said:

    Yes, I agree Facebook marketing isn’t for everyone. There might some ads that won’t be suitable to all Facebook users.

  13. Carol said:

    I agree with Jim (above) – intuitively I knew the people on Facebook or other “social media” sites were typically the younger folks doing the posting – Word of mouth is by far the best “selling” done either online or off.

    Good for GM – we dropped our social media marketing a long time ago – who we found using these apps are our competitors and rarely the customer looking for our products/services.

  14. David " Volvo Repair Tucson" Johnson said:

    I haven’t done any Facebook ads on the OEM level, but I have on the dealership level and while it’s not always perfect science we seem to do pretty good.

    For instance I did an ad in a city in New York on both Facebook and Adwords. It was for the Lincoln Navigator and both ads had the same copy. I set it for a 20 mile radius and the ad on Facebook had double the number of clicks. The conversion rate was less but it sold more vehicles than the Google ad. Also, since the clicks were less both ads spent roughly the same amount so as for as an ROI standpoint the Facebook ad was better.

  15. http://soundtrackingjohncage433.com/mediawiki/index.php?title=User:DanyqqGoo said:

    Thank you for sharing your thoughts. I really appreciate your efforts and
    I am waiting for your next post thank you once again.

  16. anna said:

    I think facebook marketing is so great.

  17. Abel said:

    My programmer is trying to persuade me to move to .net from PHP.
    I have always disliked the idea because of the expenses.
    But he’s tryiong none the less. I’ve been using Movable-type on numerous websites for about a year and am nervous about switching to another platform.

    I have heard very good things about blogengine.net. Is there a way I can import all my
    wordpress content into it? Any kind of help would be greatly appreciated!

  18. Here said:

    I liked that piece of writing. I hope you continue to keep posting, I’ll be coming back regularly. Thank you partner.

  19. Antona said:

    Very nice article, facebook is such an amazing social networks and here most of the people are wants some http://myfbhacker.com its an useful for getting the hack for fb profiles.

  20. anshu kumar said:

    very good information sharing in this article about social networking thanks for sharing important article
    facebook earn money easy way

  21. own said:

    successful Facebook Marketing examples which will help you to build a community and thriving business ratio.

    best way to promote business on Facebook

  22. Alan Voo said:

    Good day fellas! I have been using https://expert-writers.net/ service for my hometasks since the first day of my study at the university and I have never been disappointed of their essay works. Prices are excellent and the quality is the highest. Authors, keep up great work!!!

  23. One Dasty said:

    Bringing home a new puppy is a wonderful experience involving the whole family, which is why we begin training early to ease the transition to their new home and famiparations to make it less stressful. To provide a completely different environment for our puppies, we thoroughly researched and make sure this puppies will only go to respectable families
    https://pugslandbreeder.company.com

  24. McOrlando said:

    All of Pitbull,deworming,health certificate, genetic health guarantee, and AKC registration papers. All new families are required to sign a contract that includes a basic health guarantee and a 3 year genetic health guarantee. They have been raised in our home around small children, kittens and dogs of every size to help them develop well round personalities accustomed to daily home activates. We encourage families to ask question and to stay in contact with us.
    All puppies sold as pets will go home spayed-neutered! We also sell puppies along with breeding right. Note this will include an additional fee.
    https://pitbullbreeder.company.com

  25. robert said:

    https://savannahbengal.company.com/

  26. lsm99 said:

    Dollar rate 1 dollar per 33 Thai baht value that the future will afb88 too quickly. Effect on all import and export systems

  27. ????????????? said:

    Auto finance or auto financing is the phrase used when an individual wants to purchase a car but cannot give the complete required amount of the vehicle upfront. ????????????? In an auto finance process, the person buying the automobile would first make an application for auto financing.

  28. afb1188 said:

    Hi, after reading this amazing piece of writing superlot i am too happy to share my knowledge here with mates.

  29. gclub said:

    It’s very helpful King99 thanks for sharing it in preparing for what’s to come.

  30. Ndure Shoes said:

    Shop best quality casual shoes for men online in Pakistan and Sneakers from Ndure. Shop from a wide range of colours and styles, available exclusively at Ndure. Ndure Men’s Casual Shoes and Sneakers are made from best quality materials, with soft sole. Style a handsome look in Ndure Shoes.

    Shop from a wide range of Mens collection from Ndure. Shop from a wide variety of men shoes online in Pakistan, Mens chappals, sandals, sneakers, sports wear, loafers, slipons and boots from Ndure. Our shoes are made from best quality material that is durable. Shop from a wide range shoes color and style.

    Shop best quality formal dress shoes for men online Pakistan from Ndure. Shop from a wide range of colours and styles, available exclusively at Ndure. Ndure Men’s Formal Shoes are made from best quality materials, with soft shoe sole. Style a handsome look in best quality Men’s Formal Shoes.

  31. Borjan Shoes said:

    Borjan offers its customers the best quality womens backpack online in Pakistan. We have the highest quality womens backpacks for the most affordable prices. So, get Borjan’s amazing collection of backpacks for women online. Get your favorite ladies’ backpacks from Borjan to keep yourself in style and comfort at the same time.

    Borjan offers its customers the best trending necklaces for women online in Pakistan. We have the highest quality women’s necklaces for the most affordable prices. So, get Borjan’s amazing collection of necklaces for women online. Get your favorite women’s necklaces from Borjan to keep yourself in style and comfort at the same time.

  32. ???????? said:

    I used to have a look at an ebook that said When we do something, be conscious. But we must recognize what we must do. I like to play sexygame the best game online.

  33. ShopECS said:

    ECS is top shoes brands in Pakistan. Check out ECS shoes collection online.

  34. Ndure Shoes said:

    From Ndure buy the best quality cotton t-shirts online at affordable price. Fast Shipping.

    Buy online Latest fashion Athletic jogger pants men from Ndure. Fast Shipping.

    From Ndure buy the best quality chino shorts online. Fast Shipping.

    Shop from a wide range of shoes for women from Ndure. Ndure offers Women Flats chappals, sandals, sneakers, sports wear, heels and Pumps shoes for Girls. Our shoes are made from best quality material that is durable. At Ndure, we have a fashion for each one of You.

  35. Saba Khan said:

    Hello admin!!!! This article is compact, yet will walk you bit by bit into the productive business of wood bed reusing. Ultra Tec water Treatment company in Dubai UAE and
    5 stages RO cabinet water purifier is a great product.

  36. Murphy Family Mover said:

    Murphy is one of the best companies among moving companies in St Charles IL. Visit now and get the solution to your problem.

  37. ShopECS said:

    ECS is a place where you can get high quality sneakers for girls. You can get the most stunning and huge collection of shoes for you. So, visit ECS and get the shoes you like.

  38. Borjan Shoes said:

    Borjan offers its customers the best training shoes for men online in Pakistan. We have the highest quality training shoes for boys for the most affordable prices. Get Borjan’s amazing collection of men’s training shoes online. Get your favorite shoes for men from Borjan to enjoy style and comfort at the same time.

  39. Metro Shoes said:

    Metro shoes offers their customers the highest quality ladies sandals and sandal designs. Get the best available Women Sandals in Pakistan, today. So, buy the best sandals for girls online from Metro shoes. We bring you only the highest quality sandals for women.

  40. Servis Shoes said:

    Servis PK is an Online Official Store, where you can buy formal shoes for men in all sizes with various colors at reasonable Prices. We deliver a product on COD in all Metro cities like Lahore, Karachi, Islamabad across Pakistan.

  41. Maples Closet said:

    Buy stylish shoulder bags for women at Maples Closet, your premier destination for modest fashion in the UAE. Explore our exquisite collection of shoulder bags, meticulously designed to embody the beauty and elegance of traditional Islamic clothing while embracing modern fashion trends.

  42. 123bet said:

    Free hippocampus, there is a foolish game LIVE, dragon tiger, baccarat, baccarat

  43. Robert green said:

    When it comes to CT scan in Bangalore , trust the expertise of the dedicated team at the leading CT Scan Diagnostic Centre, delivering precise results and compassionate care.

  44. William said:

    Your search for the perfect PG ends here – choose from the best PGs in Bellandur , thoughtfully designed to cater to your every need.

  45. Christian Grey said:

    Get more for less with our cheap phone plans, ensuring you stay connected while saving big on your monthly bill.

  46. Christian Grey said:

    Get more for less with our cheap phone plans , ensuring you stay connected while saving big on your monthly bill.

  47. ayan said:

    Guesto living is the perfect place for you, if you are looking for best and affordable co-living places/ hourly rooms in Bangalore.

  48. valleerealestate said:

    Valleerealestate offers a curated selection of Condos For Sale in Coquitlam, catering to diverse preferences and budgets. Experience the perfect harmony of urban amenities and outdoor recreation as you explore the vibrant condominium market in Coquitlam.

  49. BSNS Consulting said:

    Based in Pakistan, BSNS Consulting is a leading Digital Marketing Agency Islamabad. Our talented team of marketers, designers, and strategists collaborates to create impactful digital campaigns that resonate with your target audience. With a focus on innovation and results, we empower your brand to thrive in the digital landscape.

  50. BSNS Consulting said:

    BSNS Consulting offers comprehensive Digital Marketing Services in Pakistan, tailored to your business needs. From SEO and content marketing to social media management and paid advertising, our team crafts data-driven strategies to amplify your online presence. Experience measurable growth and a strong return on investment with our dynamic digital marketing solutions.

  51. BSNS Consulting said:

    BSNS Consulting offers cutting-edge Services of Web Development, delivering seamless and visually stunning websites that reflect your brand’s identity. Our skilled web developers combine aesthetics with functionality, creating user-friendly platforms that drive traffic and conversions. Stay ahead in the digital landscape with our customised web development solutions.

  52. CAvpshost said:

    Discover the advantages of a cheap VPS server running on the Windows operating system. Our Cheap VPS Server Windows offers cost-effective solutions for your Windows-based server needs. With dedicated resources, root access, and the flexibility to install any Windows-compatible software, our cheap VPS server for Windows provides the perfect platform for your applications or websites. Enjoy reliable performance, robust security, and expert technical support tailored to your requirements.

  53. BSNS Consulting said:

    Trust BSNS Consulting as your reliable Taxation Services Provider. With our in-depth understanding of tax laws and regulations, we ensure accurate and timely tax compliance for your business. Our proactive tax planning approach aims to minimise tax burdens and maximise savings, allowing you to focus on driving your business forward.

  54. Tiptop-Einrichtung said:

    An Elektrische Kosmetikliege is an electric cosmetic bed or treatment table used in beauty salons and spas. The electric functionality allows for easy adjustment of the bed’s height and incline, making it suitable for various beauty and cosmetic procedures.

  55. CAvpshost said:

    With CaVPS Host’s Remote Desktop VPS, experience an exceptional level of remote access and control over your virtual server. Our services are designed to facilitate seamless connections, enabling you to manage your server resources efficiently. Enjoy a secure and user-friendly experience for all your computing needs.

  56. iHost VPS said:

    Buy VPS online suggests purchasing a virtual private server from hosting providers via their online platforms. It emphasises the convenience of acquiring VPS hosting solutions through digital channels, with instant access and setup.

  57. Vallee Real Estate.. said:

    Explore exclusive property for sale New Westminster with Vallee Real Estate’s top real estate agents. Our personalized service takes you on a journey through the vibrant offerings of Canada’s property market, ensuring you discover and acquire your dream home with ease.

  58. Growth said:

    Slow-Release Fertilizers

  59. TipTop Enrichtung said:

    A barberstuhl is a specialized chair used in barbershops. It is designed to provide comfort to male clients and facilitate optimal working posture for the barber.hese chairs often have a classic design and can be antique or retro-styled.

  60. Vallee Real Estate said:

    Discover exquisite New Westminster houses with Vallee Real Estate. Explore stunning homes in this vibrant community. Find your perfect match and experience luxury living at its finest. Trust Vallee Real Estate to guide you to your dream home.

  61. CHOICEMALL said:

    Ordinary Products at ChoiceMall.pk! Discover budget-friendly essentials for daily life. From household necessities to personal care, find unbeatable value in every purchase. Shop smart, shop ordinary, exclusively at ChoiceMall.pk

    Elevate your skincare with the Ordinary Retinol and the ordinary glycolic acid at ChoiceMall.pk! Unleash the power of this transformative ingredient for radiant skin. Trust ChoiceMall.pk for quality beauty essentials. Glow confidently with Ordinary Retinol

  62. CHOICEMALL said:

    Boost hair growth with effective hair growth serum at ChoiceMall.pk. Discover top choices for luscious locks. Elevate your hair care routine. Shop now

    Revitalize your face with Vitamin C Serum at ChoiceMall.pk. Explore top choices for radiant skin. Elevate your skincare routine. Shop now

  63. CHOICEMALL said:

    Discover the perfect hair dryer for fast, efficient styling. Designed for all hair types, it ensures a smooth, professional finish. Shop now for the best deals!

    Check out the latest hair dryer machine price in Pakistan . Affordable, high-quality options for salon-worthy results at home. Buy today for unbeatable value!

  64. choicemall said:

    Exfoliate deeply with AHA BHA The Ordinary . Perfect for refining your skin’s texture and achieving a healthy glow. Shop now for radiant skin!

    Find the best The Ordinary Peeling Solution price in Pakistan . Ideal for anyone looking to enhance their skincare routine. Buy today!

  65. Antonio hunt said:

    Thank you for sharing such important information, which is hard to come across in normal.

Leave a Reply